The following text is
copyright 2013 by Network World, permission is hearby
given for reproduction, as long as attribution is given and this notice is
The end of an extraordinarily
life: Aaron Schwartz
By: Scott Bradner
I had already submitted my last column when I heard about
Aaron Swartz. Some might say that it is too late to comment on this story since
the crowd has moved on but I think it is never too late to write about someone
you knew. I did not know Aaron
well, I had spent a few days in a retreat he was also in about 5 years ago, but
I knew his work. He was everything
that all the coverage you have already read talked about, extraordinarily smart,
extraordinarily nice and extraordinarily dedicated to making the right things
chance would have it, I also know one of the prosecutors in the case, Stephen Heymann, about as well -- having talked with him about the
same amount of time. In some ways,
Heymann and Schwartz are not all that different -
both are (or were) smart and dedicated to their view of "right."
has been unleashed on the prosecutors office in this
case. At this point I do not think
that any of the people not directly involved know enough of what happened in
detail but, as many have said, including U.S. Attorney Carmen Ortiz, the actual
charges Aaron was facing were widely out of proportion with what he had
done. Even the widely reported 6
month sentence being offered as part of a plea deal is far too high a price to
pay for attempting to make a pile of scholarly articles freely available.
it was a refusal on the part of MIT to accept a lesser penalty, as has been
reported, that kept Ortiz and Heymann from agreeing
to a penalty more in line with what Aaron actually did. We should know at some point because
MIT, to its credit, appointed Professor Hal Abelson, perhaps the one MIT person
that could be trusted to fully tell MIT and the rest of us the truth, to
investigate MIT's actions.
sad, very sad. Aaron was a good
guy, a very good guy. He made the
Internet, and thus the world, a better place by what he did -- starting when he
was barely a teen. He accomplished
more in his 26 years than almost any other fighter for the right that I can
think of has accomplished in twice as many years. Aaron was 4 years younger than the Internet (if you measure
from the deployment of TCP/IP) - he spent the whole of his life in the world of
the Internet and he swam so smoothly and powerfully in that world.
I am also angry - a sad angry - that Aaron was subject to
the law rather than to justice.
For that I, at this point with incomplete information, blame MIT as well
as the prosecutors office. We will
know more about MITs role when Professor Abelson
makes his report and I hope that we will find out more about paths not taken by
the prosecutors office in the future.
At this point I do not know what to feel about the role of
Stephen Heymann. From what I saw in him during our talks I fully expect he
felt he was doing the right thing.
But I do wish that his right thing had not contributed to the death of a
person who had so much more to give to the world.
disclaimer: Harvard has not expressed any opinion on
Aaron's activities or his death so the above lament is mine.